Review Criteria is where you can create a pre-defined list of review criteria for your reviewers to use during their review process.
Some ideas for review criteria include:
- Content
- Accuracy
- Relevance
- Visual Appeal
- Anything you can imagine!
The fields in Review Criteria are:
- Name - the name of the criterion.
- Score Type - these are the ways your reviewers can input their rating of these criteria:
- Check Box - the reviewer will check a box to indicate the criterion has been met. (Also enter the weighting percentage for this condition here.)
- Date - to record any date relevant to the paper review.
- Score - number that falls in a pre-set range. (Also enter the range, and the weighting percentage for this condition here.)
- Number - good for numbers that may not fall in a known range. (e.g. word count)
- Percentage - number out of a hundred.
- Tag - select the review value from tags.
- Text - free-form text, for when no other category carries enough information.
Caution: Once you Save, the Score Type cannot be changed.
- Display Ordering - you can assign the order in which each criterion is displayed on the screen, with lower numbers being higher on the list than larger numbers.
- Weighting - enter a weighting percentage number for this specific review criterion.